2 and Jibba laughing over the poem
I Ruined your Face is a poem written by a Seattle man who had threatend to kill his girlfriend. When the story was reported in Show 158, it caused both 2 and Jibba to break into uncontrollable laughter for over a minute. Even after they had calmed down, random bursts of laughter would persist into the remainder of the show, and continued on for about an hour after the show.
It is now considered a running joke in the fandom, sometimes 2 Sense brings it up in stories whenever it involves the ruin of faces in the story, or variants (like in episode #174 where they made the quip about how the woman who killed a man with boiling water "ruined his everything").